WiiDebate Member VC Game Ratings

NES
The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past - 90%
Super Mario Bros. - 70%

StarTropics
Metroid
The Legend of Zelda
Kirby's Adventure
Neutopia 2
Lords of Thunder

SNES
Super Mario World - 90%

Donkey Kong Country
Donkey Kong Country 3
DoReMi Fantasy

Genesis

TurboGrafx16
Bomberman 93 - 85%

N64
F-Zero X - 100%
Paper Mario - 100%
Starfox 64 - 93%
Super Mario 64 - 90%
Mario Kart 64 - 88%
Pokemon Snap - 80%
Yoshi's Story - 70%
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 65%

Sin and Punishment
1080 Snowboarding
Kirby 64

This post was last modified: 04-09-2008 01:08 AM by KnucklesSonic8.

Changed focus of the topic. People rate (from 1-10, no decimals) each VC Game they've played. Once two people rate a specific game, I'll begin to construct an Average Rating (%) based on your ratings. Think like MetaCritics' formula in a way.

Give a small one sentence comment summarizing your thoughts on the game (try including biggest strength and weakness if possible) as this will have later significance also.

I'll update the first post when I'm on my computer.


Feel free to rate originals you've played/have but dont have on the VC.

I'll rate a few now:
StarTropics: 9
- A fantastic game like this deserves to be in the company of Zelda, incorporating RPG-like elements and an even greater puzzle element that bring the package together.

Super Mario 64: 9
- This cult-classic is truly memorable but if you've played Mario's more recent outings, this fantastic game may be hard to come back to.

Bomberman 93: 9
- Where the single-player falls a bit short, the frantic multiplayer greatly makes up for.

Metroid: 9/10
Many design flaws, but the GIANT fun factor makes up for it.

The Legend of Zelda - 9/10
Suffers Replay Value problems, otherwise, great game.

Bomberman '93 - 8/10
Not much in terms of a single player, but a brilliant multiplayer.

Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 10/10
Probably the greatest and one of the most difficult games in the Zelda series.

LOZ: Ocarina of Time - 3/10
A disappointing, boring, short and OVERRATED conversion to 3D

LOZ: A Link to the Past - 10/10
Amazingly designed, replayable game, with many fun puzzles and bosses.

Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past - 8/10
Probably the best 2D Zelda game. A great storyline and a very challenging game.

Pokemon Snap - 9/10
An extremely fun game with a lot of replay value.

Updated.

More ratings:
Donkey Kong Country: 8/10
-This game reeks of nostalgia and it's widely considered to be the greatest start to one of the greatest platformers in gaming history.

Donkey Kong Country 3: 9/10
- A very underrated game in the DKC series, but despite this, not only are both the level design and music is fantastic, but the game's overall progression is certainly worthy of recognition.

Super Mario World: 10/10
- Absolutely amazing, worth all the Points you spend on it.

Kirby's Adventure: 9/10
- A classic Kirby game filled with joy and admirable level design, certainly worth the Point requirement.

BTW this should be stickied if it isnt

Mario kart 64 (10/10)
-great story and amazing replay value. i still play this 2day

Super mario bros. (8/10)
- a classic must have with endless fun.
-good to play with parents
-only 500 pionts. definately worth it.

i was going to rate all of my vc games but i realized how long that would take, so i decided to rate two underrated gems.

lords of thunder: 9/10

pros: the best "space" shooter on the VC, awesome music if you like metal music playing with your game,

cons: the metal music can be a con if you don't like that kind of music and
the difficullty can be a pro or a con.

neutopia 2: 9/10

pro's: a great zelda clone (this is a pro and a con.) plays alot like the legend of zelda: a link to the past and this game was made before a link to the past, replay value for some (like me.) i could see some people not playing this game more then once but only if they didn't enjoy the game in the first place.

cons: a zelda clone, the difficulty in the later levels could be a turn off for some.

Rating N64 stuff for now:

Super Mario 64 - 10/10 - Great game, definately worth everyone's time.

Mario Kart 64 - 8/10 - Also quite good, but outclassed by Double Dash and DS, IMO. I can't go back to playing this after playing the above two, for some reason.

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time - 9/10 - Would give this a 9.5 if I could. This is NOT the "best Zelda ever" or something like that, but it's quite good indeed.

Lylat Wars (Starfox 64) - 9/10 - Great replay value, most quotable game of all time, nice gameplay, what more could you want? Although it is quite short, going for highscores can make you play this for a long time.

F-Zero X - 10/10 - Best racing game on the N64. Great speed, course design, character selection and especially music. Very hard on higher difficulties, but not F-Zero GX Story Mode level. Would be even better if they'd release the expansion kit.

Paper Mario - 10/10 - Not the best Mario RPG title (that'd be Paper Mario The Thousand-Year Door for GC), but still awesome. Great battle system, huge worlds to explore, tons of items to collect, hilarious characters, 25ish hours to play through. Great RPG, get it.

Sin and Punishment - 7/10 - Nice gameplay, harder difficulties are a real challenge, but confusing story and quite short. Get this if you're a fan of rail shooters, but otherwise pass.

Yoshi's Story - 9/10 - Sure, it's no Yoshi's Island or Mario World, but it's quite fun anyway. 24 levels to explore, good gameplay, and a high-score mode to shoot for top scores. Sure, it probably gets the title for "quickest N64 game to see the ending ever if you beat each level as fast as possible", but that's not fun now, is it?

Pokémon Snap - 7/10 - It's nice, but FAR too short, and on rails. If you could run around and there were more Pokémon/levels, then this would be an instant clasisc, but alas, it only has 6 (+1) levels and 50ish mons.

1080° Snowboarding - no score - Honestly, I never could get into this game. We got this more-or-less for free from my uncle, but me and my friend really never used it for something else except mindless fun in trying to see who dies faster or who can make the most ridiculous jump. Yes, we had great fun doing that, but... I dunno, I'm not sure.

Will rate more later, probably.